Newsletter 62: Understanding the Differences Between Service Dogs, Therapy Dogs, and Emotional Support Animals
Subject: Not All Helper Dogs Are the Same — Here’s What Sets Them Apart
Dogs have long served as loyal companions, but some go beyond companionship into life-changing roles. From assisting individuals with disabilities to providing emotional comfort in schools and hospitals, dogs can serve in powerful and specific ways.
But not all helper dogs are the same. Terms like service dog, therapy dog, and emotional support animal (ESA) are often used interchangeably—but they represent very different legal classifications, training standards, and public access rights.
Let’s break it down so you know exactly what each role means—and what it doesn’t.
🐕🦺 What Is a Service Dog?
Definition: A service dog is individually trained to perform specific tasks that mitigate a person’s physical, sensory, psychiatric, or other disability.
✅ Key Points:
Protected under the ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act)
Legally allowed to accompany their handler into any public space (stores, restaurants, planes, etc.)
Must be trained to perform tasks directly related to the person’s disability
Not required to wear a vest or carry documentation (though many do for clarity)
🛠️ Examples of Service Dog Tasks:
Guiding the visually impaired
Alerting to oncoming seizures or blood sugar drops
Retrieving dropped items
Interrupting self-harming behaviors in psychiatric conditions
🐾 What Is a Therapy Dog?
Definition: A therapy dog is trained to provide comfort and affection to individuals in hospitals, schools, nursing homes, disaster areas, and more—but is not trained to assist one specific person.
✅ Key Points:
Not protected under the ADA
Requires permission to enter facilities (invited presence only)
Must pass public access tests and maintain calm, tolerant behavior in unpredictable environments
Often certified by therapy dog organizations, but not required by law
🛠️ Therapy Dog Roles:
Visiting patients in hospitals to reduce stress and depression
Participating in reading programs for children
Providing calm presence during therapy or grief counseling
🧸 What Is an Emotional Support Animal (ESA)?
Definition: An ESA provides emotional comfort through presence—not trained tasks—and is prescribed by a mental health professional to assist with conditions like anxiety, PTSD, or depression.
✅ Key Points:
Not a service dog and not trained to perform specific tasks
No public access rights under the ADA
May have limited housing protections under the Fair Housing Act
No access to non-pet-friendly public places (restaurants, stores, etc.)
🛠️ ESA Examples:
A dog that calms a person during panic attacks by simply being nearby
A cat whose presence reduces insomnia or depression symptoms
🚫 Common Misconceptions
“I can take my ESA into a restaurant.”
➤ False. ESAs do not have public access rights under federal law.“Therapy dogs can go everywhere service dogs can.”
➤ False. Only service dogs are allowed full access by law.“A doctor’s note makes my dog a service dog.”
➤ False. Service dogs must be trained to perform specific tasks—diagnosis alone isn’t enough.
🎯 Why These Differences Matter
Clarity helps protect the rights of individuals with legitimate service animals, maintains safety in public spaces, and preserves the integrity of working dog roles. Mislabeling dogs—intentionally or not—can lead to access being denied for those who truly depend on their trained companions.
📚 Recommended Reading:
“The ADA National Network Guide to Service Animals and Emotional Support Animals” (free PDF)
Provides simple, accurate explanations of legal definitions and access rights.
💬 Quote We’re Pondering:
“A dog can change your life—but the role they serve must be honored and understood.” — Unknown
Whether your dog offers emotional support, therapeutic companionship, or performs life-saving tasks, their impact is real—and their category matters.
Stay informed. Stay respectful. And if you’re pursuing a working role for your dog, we’re here to help guide the journey.
Warm regards,
The Team at Double H Canine
Would you like to follow this with a paid subscriber version that includes legal FAQs, public behavior expectations, and how to prepare dogs for each path?